Reference: Article in New York Times: New F.B.I. Files Describe Abuse of Iraq Inmates
When a country is full of scared people, that is the time when the wolves, tigers, jackels and thieves take advantage. Like with the classic tale of Chicken Little. A single acorn drops on the head of a stupid chicken and next thing one knows the entire barn-yard is agaggle with panicky animals. Only human animals are dangerous when they are afraid. They are likely to forget that they are human. The world of animality is a world of brutality; A world that forget's it is human. A world where it is entirely possible for supposedly civilized people to act like Brutes. And that is why it is all the more important during times of crises to remember that we create civilizations....
....That for all the fear that we feel, compared to a real "fin de sicle" event, the attacks of 9/11 were an acorn. More importantly, when a threat is real one has to correctly identify where it is coming from and how to meet it.
One response that does not past muster is the panic response; the Brute response; the tribal response. Reports of "detainees' being beaten and choked and having lit cigarettes placed in their ears" are not funny. They are not acceptable behavior. They are not an appropriate response. And they are no way to resist Islamic fundamentalists. For the US to openly embrace policies based on brute force and repression in our foreign policy is to set us up to use brute force and recession at home. And that is why these things need to be stopped.
These behaviors are clear and simply criminal. The FBI is coming public with these accusations because they are accusations of illegal behavior that has nothing to do with professional interrogations and law enforcement. They know that the American people, and our leaders, have to recognize that not only do these kinds of behaviors not work; for all the neo-Nazi Berretta, Rambo and Terminator films to the contrary, they don't even get results. One cannot touch evil without it contaminating the hand that touches. A "Berretta" with his gun shooting "bad guys" is apt to eventually become a bad guy himself; perhaps shooting his own wife eventually. The way of anger is a bad way. It is not patriotism, it is prelude to fascism. It is not law enforcement, it is law-breaking.
In case you haven't seen these. This was the memo from Alberto R. Gonzales -- soon to be the new Justice Department Chief:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/nation/documents/dojinterrogationmemo20020801.pdf
He was willing to redefine torture to permit a wide range of activities that most of the world considers torture. But of course once one lets such things go, it gets worse. Todays post comments:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A20986-2004Dec22.html
including "beatings, chokings, prolonged sleep deprivation and humiliations such as being wrapped in an Israeli flag."
John Ashcroft, who at least had the sense to feel enough shame to leave the administration when his term expired testified back a while ago:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A25211-2004Jun8.html
Yet even so he lied under oath about the dangers of Padilla at that hearing. Either he lied about those dangers when he described him as a "dangerous man" on his arrest, or lied when they turned him loose almost two years later. The senators noted that fact. I still remember watching Ashcrofts reaction. It still gives me the chills. And now Bush is rewarding a man who has even less of a sense of shame about these things.
Miller lied under oath about using dogs in interrogations. He's been contradicted by the testimony of FBI agents ashamed at what is going on. Yet Miller was the one who was promoted and sent in to "clean up" Abu Gharaib when the Patsy's there were left holding the bag.
What a shame!
Posted by: chris at December 23, 2004 11:59 AMThere is more on this at these sites:
http://billmon.org/archives/001452.html
I'm not the only one aghast at the promotions of Miller and Alberto Gonzales.
And this site, run by Jewish people with a conscience details how Israel was using similar behaviors and how the high court there stopped them in 1999:
http://www.stoptorture.org.il/eng/background.asp?menu=3&submenu=1
Those methods are still in use.
Posted by: chris at December 23, 2004 12:22 PM